Brokers Recommend Buying Old Mutual, Advising Profit-Taking from Banks
South Africa’s financial sector, a microcosm of the nation’s economic journey, presents a compelling yet intricate landscape for investors in 2024.
Old Mutual, a titan within this sector, exemplifies this complexity. Despite recent gains mirroring a broader South African stock market rally, the company’s performance trails its peers. This underperformance, however, unveils a potential value proposition for investors with a long-term perspective.
Old Mutual’s Mixed Performance and Strategic Shift:
While 2024 hasn’t been stellar for Old Mutual in terms of absolute returns, the year has been marked by contrasting developments. The company participated in the recent upswing in South African equities, including its own stock.
However, this rise hasn’t been enough to erase the year-to-date deficit – Old Mutual remains 8% below its starting position. This has widened the performance gap with its industry peers, potentially making it an attractive target for value investors seeking undervalued stocks with room for growth.
However, a closer look reveals a company navigating both internal growth opportunities and external challenges. The first-quarter business update released in May 2024 showcased robust growth in new life insurance policies issued domestically.
This indicates a healthy appetite for Old Mutual’s core insurance products within South Africa. Conversely, the picture across the rest of Africa is less rosy. Currency devaluations in several African markets continue to squeeze profitability in those operations. In response, Old Mutual has embarked on a strategic portfolio streamlining effort.
The aim is to exit smaller-scale operations on the continent and capitalize on recent currency stabilizations. This strategic shift signifies a focus on core competencies and potentially higher-margin markets.
Technical Analysis: Bullish Signals and Investment Strategy:
Investors seeking to capitalize on Old Mutual’s potential turnaround can find guidance in technical analysis. Recently, the company’s stock price crossed above its 200-day moving average. This technical indicator is often interpreted as a signal of a potential shift in investor sentiment towards optimism.
The 200-day moving average now acts as a critical support level, suggesting that market participants are increasingly confident about the company’s future prospects.
Building on this technical analysis, financial brokers recommend an entry range between R12 to R13 per share. This entry point balances potential upside with a degree of risk management. The target price is set at R14, representing a potential upside of 16.8% from current levels.
This targeted return reflects the belief in Old Mutual’s ability to close the performance gap with its peers. To mitigate risk, brokers recommend a stop-loss order at R11 per share. This ensures that potential losses are capped in case the stock price takes an unexpected downturn.
Contrasting Landscape: South African Banks and the Need for Caution:
While Old Mutual presents a potentially attractive value play, the outlook for South African banks, excluding Capitec, is less clear-cut. The recent surge in banking sector stock prices was primarily driven by the announcement of a government of national unity (GNU).
However, this rapid ascent has propelled these stocks into what some analysts consider “overbought territory.” This technical term suggests that the recent price gains may not be sustainable in the short term.
Financial experts caution that this rapid rise in bank stock prices could trigger profit-taking among short-term investors. This profit-taking, coupled with ongoing political uncertainties surrounding the GNU, could lead to a corrective phase in the banking sector. While this correction may be temporary, it could establish a more stable foundation for future market gains.
Challenges and Opportunities in the Banking Sector:
Beyond the immediate correction risk, South African banks face several structural headwinds. Potential increases in credit impairments due to non-performing loans are a major concern. Additionally, the lack of significant interest rate hikes limits the banks’ ability to generate net interest income, a key source of profitability. Transactional revenue, another crucial source of income, may also face constraints due to the evolving financial landscape.
However, there are glimmers of optimism within the broader financial sector. High-quality retail stocks are experiencing similar market dynamics as banks. Yet, these retailers benefit from a more resilient near-term earnings outlook compared to banks. This relative resilience stems from the continued demand for consumer goods and services, even during periods of economic uncertainty.
Looking forward, financial brokers express interest in re-entering positions in South African banks once their prices adjust to approximately 10% below current levels. This potential correction presents a strategic buying opportunity for investors with a longer-term perspective. By waiting for a more attractive entry point, investors can potentially mitigate the risk of overpaying for bank stocks in the current overbought market environment.
Conclusion: Strategic Investment Decisions in a Dynamic Landscape:
Navigating the complexities of South Africa’s financial sector requires a nuanced understanding of both the underlying economic fundamentals and the evolving market sentiment.
While Old Mutual presents a potential value opportunity with its recent underperformance and strategic shift, investors must carefully consider the company’s exposure to African currency fluctuations.
Similarly, the outlook for South African banks, though potentially attractive after a correction, hinges on the country’s economic trajectory and the effectiveness of the newly formed government.
Beyond Value and Technicals: Thematic Considerations
Beyond traditional value investing and technical analysis, incorporating thematic considerations into investment decisions can offer valuable insights. South Africa, like many nations, is grappling with several key themes that will shape its future economic landscape. These themes include:
- Digital Transformation: The financial sector is undergoing a rapid digital transformation, with the rise of Fintech (financial technology) companies disrupting traditional models. Investors should evaluate how well-positioned Old Mutual and South African banks are to adapt and capitalize on this trend.
- Sustainability: Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations are increasingly influencing investor decisions. Assessing Old Mutual and South African banks’ commitment to sustainable practices can offer valuable insights into their long-term prospects.
- Infrastructure Development: South Africa’s infrastructure deficit is a significant drag on economic growth.
Understanding how Old Mutual and banks might play a role in financing infrastructure projects can inform investment decisions.
By incorporating these thematic considerations alongside traditional analysis, investors can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the potential risks and rewards associated with investing in South African financial institutions.
We hope this information has been very useful to you.
Thank you very much for reading us.
Follow our website for more information on cards, loans and finance!
